They Said Buy

Call record / Creator leaderboard

How creators’ stock calls
did against the market

Each creator–stock record counts once: its first clear forecast, from the first close after the video, set against the S&P 500 over the same six months.

Method v2 updated

How records are scored
147 creator × stock recordsPrice data · Nov 2, 2026

The standings

Places, once the samples allow them.

10+ matured calls for a place

Some records on this board were corrected on Oct 10, 2026. See the corrections log.

Ordered by the rate pulled towards 50% while samples are small. One creator’s calls on one stock count as one result. Open a record to see the evidence.

  1. Place 1

    Tom Nash

    16 stock records 11 scored 2 in progress

    73%8 of 11 beat the market

    Likely range 43–90%

    Beat the market
    8
    Lagged the market
    3
    In line with the market
    2
    In progress
    2
    Not scored
    1
    Inspect Tom Nash’s 16 stock records

    All 16 records on Tom Nash’s page →

  2. Place 2

    Jeremy Lefebvre

    19 stock records 15 scored 4 in progress

    53%8 of 15 beat the market

    Likely range 30–75%

    Beat the market
    8
    Lagged the market
    7
    In line with the market
    0
    In progress
    4
    Not scored
    0
    Inspect Jeremy Lefebvre’s 19 stock records

    All 19 records on Jeremy Lefebvre’s page →

  3. Place 3

    Joseph Carlson

    20 stock records 15 scored 2 in progress

    33%5 of 15 beat the market

    Likely range 15–58%

    Beat the market
    5
    Lagged the market
    10
    In line with the market
    0
    In progress
    2
    Not scored
    3
    Inspect Joseph Carlson’s 20 stock records

    All 20 records on Joseph Carlson’s page →

  4. Place 4

    Everything Money

    21 stock records 10 scored 2 in progress

    10%1 of 10 beat the market

    Likely range 2–40%

    Beat the market
    1
    Lagged the market
    9
    In line with the market
    0
    In progress
    2
    Not scored
    9
    Inspect Everything Money’s 21 stock records

    All 21 records on Everything Money’s page →

Building a record

Records still maturing.

9 with fewer than 10 matured calls

A call matures six months after its first close. Each card shows how many calls have matured, how many are in progress and when the next one matures.

The small print, made readable

A score you can check.

This is a calculation under the method below on the quotes and prices shown. It covers selected calls with different starting dates, not a creator’s entire track record, skill or portfolio return.

Against the market, once per record

We start at the first clear bullish or bearish forecast on each creator–stock page, at the first close after the video. After six months (126 trading days) the stock is compared with SPY over the same dates: more than 2 percentage points ahead is “beat”, more than 2 behind is “lagged”, in between is “in line”. A bearish call is scored the other way round. A later opposite forecast or a sale ends the call early; a call reversed within 20 trading days is not scored.

The rate

Beat ÷ (beat + lagged) × 100

Calls in line with the market, in progress or not scored stay visible and are left out of the percentage. The order uses the rate pulled towards 50% while a sample is small: (beat + 5) ÷ (matured calls + 10).

Places need a sample

A place needs 10 matured calls, and places appear once 3 creators have them. The likely range is a 95% Wilson interval; a creator is called above or below 50% only with 20 matured calls and a range that leaves 50% out.

How records are selected

A record is a creator and a stock they discussed repeatedly in their videos since September 10, 2025. It holds the quotes chosen from those videos, word for word, and counts once here however many quotes it has. A record without a clear bullish or bearish forecast, one with opposing views on the same day, and one whose view changed within 20 trading days is shown but not scored.

Each call’s outcome is frozen after six months, so later prices do not change it; calls still maturing can move until then. Read the full methodology →